Melbourne's Docklands is still a depressing wasteland

Unless I’m mistaken, the whole reason VicUrban redeveloped Melbourne’s Docklands was to stop people from climbing the Rialto Tower and asking Melbournians what the hell that big open space with nothing much going on was to the west of the city.
Well it’s 2009 now and sadly nothing much has changed.
Melbourne’s Lord Mayor, Robert Doyle made the news over comments he made recently about the Docklands;
Docklands lacks the “social glue” of other suburbs and needs urgent reinvigoration, says Lord Mayor Robert Doyle.
Cr Doyle said he was “very worried about Docklands”, which lacked the “social glue” that other suburbs took for granted. “At the micro level it doesn’t work. Where would you take your kids to kick the footy? Where would you have a casual beer?”
“I think one of the key things is to link Docklands better with the city,” he said, adding it was almost like two cities, with “a very clear separation between the two”.
Now this was back in March and I made a note on my list of stuff to write about to get down there and check it out. Here we are at the end of May and I finally managed to get down there to take it in for myself.
Yes, that’s how much of a joke it is going to the Docklands. Despite living just fifteen to twenty odd minutes away by bike I had to actually plan a trip down there because apart from observing how deserted and crap it is, there really isn’t much reason to go there. Tasmania feels closer to Melbourne then the Docklands does.
Anyway, last Saturday I trudged out on my bike on a reasonably sunny day and armed with my camera decided to document whether the place was swimming in success or drowning in decay. Here’s what I found:

This is the first thing you see coming from the city to the Docklands by bike. It’s some dark and uninviting street with some buildings and two trees. There was absolutely nobody around except for one guy crossing the street, mind you this was lunchtime on a reasonably sunny Saturday too.
It looks like an utter hole.
This theme is continued throughout the suburb, or more appropriately ‘bunch of tall buildings with roads’.

I have no idea what the barriers were doing there on the road. Perhaps the council was protecting people from something even more depressing then the vast nothingess surrounding the area. It was probably an open lot child graveyard. Infact I’m pretty sure that’s exactly what the barriers were protecting me from.

The change from the CBD to the Docklands is dramatic. I could have stripped down and rubbed myself all over those posts and nobody would ever know
As you’re walking around pretending you’re Will Smith from ‘I am Legend, you’ll easily notice the huge areas of grey nothingness. Giant football fields of concrete are reserved for art sculptures that take up about 0.1% of the space they sit on.

Yes that metal spaghetti thing in the middle is a sculpture and yes it probably cost us hundreds of thousands of dollars...
I mean what, did the developers seriously think thousands of people were just going to come to the Docklands to stand around in big open spaces to look at sculptures? It’s not a once or even twice off thing either, it seems everywhere you look there’s another giant slab of concrete with some obscure uninviting piece of urban art on it.
The main walkway and when I say main I assume it’s the main walkway because there a few people about, was littered with overpriced trendy cafes. The cafes seemed to be doing ok but why you’d come out all this way just for a $15 coffee is beyond me.

The shopping district was a similar story to the rest of the place. Most of the stores there seemed to be clearance shoe stores and really… there’s only so many pairs of shoes you can buy.


One thing I did notice when cycling around was that the Docklands is the most bike friendly suburb in Melbourne. All the streets seemed to have a bike lane and there was ample parking facilities everywhere, even if there was nobody around to use them.

To top it off pretty much no matter where you go in the Docklands, you’ve almost always got a visual on what was supposed to be a huge tourist puller, the Southern Star Observation Wheel. I won’t go into the details here as I’ve already covered its collosal failure earlier this year.

The only redeeming feature the Docklands has going for it is the Costco store which is currently being built.

Expected to be open sometime in July pending catastrophic heat failure, Costco will actually give people a reason to go to the Docklands as it will be the first store of it’s kind in Australia. With multiple carparks adjacent to the store location though, there still won’t be much incentive to stay around the Docklands after shopping there.
So that pretty much sums up an afternoon at the Docklands. It’s a dark bleak uninviting pocket tucked away in the rectum of the CBD. I have no idea why anyone would want to live there except for the ease of jumping on a tram or walking into the cbd to work. Unless you had multiple levels of awesome in your apartment, I can’t imagine why you’d want to spend the weekend there though.
Apart from stopping by once Costco is open to check it out I doubt i’ll be going back there anytime soon. What a waste of potential and god knows how many millions of dollars.





May 25th, 2009 at 5:17 pm Van(Quote)
Dude! Where are the zombies?!? I cannot believe the area is so empty.
Sure, you don’t give a time of day… I mean Chicago could look dead at 5:00AM BUT I’m assuming this is during the day.
I’m a bit surprised.
May 25th, 2009 at 6:32 pm Jeb(Quote)
Glad you mentioned the bike facilities – that’s one of the few things the area’s good for. Not just the facilities themselves but the total lack of cars around, as well.
May 25th, 2009 at 9:31 pm ozsoapbox(Quote)
@Van: I did mention the time!
I’m pretty sure the barriers set up on that road were the only thing keeping the zombies at bay.
@Jeb: The bike facilities are amazing at the Docklands, everywhere you go there are giant rows of empty bicycle stands it’s great. If only there was a reason to ride there beyond using it as a city bypass to get into the western suburbs.
May 25th, 2009 at 9:33 pm Jeb(Quote)
A nice bike ride is to go through the Docklands, then around to Lorimer Street. Follow that un-picturesque road and you’ll arrive at Westgate Park, then you can ride around to Port Melbourne’s beaches. From there you can follow the great bike path along the 109 tram line back to where you came from. Not a bad little ride.
May 25th, 2009 at 9:44 pm ozsoapbox(Quote)
Is that the road that leads down to the punt and then that big park under city link?
If so I do that ride a fair bit and agree it’s pretty relaxing. Lorimer road can be a bit boring but it’s pretty interesting if there’s a big ship being unloaded on your right. Some of those cranes are huge… as I’m riding past I secretely wish the guy would swing the crane around and let the shipping container fly – that’d be so awesome to watch.
I reckon he could get it to the otherside of the river, easy!
May 25th, 2009 at 9:46 pm Jeb(Quote)
That’s the one! And yeah Lorimer isn’t bad if you’re not there during peak hour.
May 25th, 2009 at 9:50 pm ozsoapbox(Quote)
There’s a peak hour there?
Every time I’ve ridden down there seriously it’s as deserted as the docklands themselves. I just assumed all those businesses were mafia fronts or something.
Nobody really drives down there to buy anything do they?
May 26th, 2009 at 9:29 am Van(Quote)
I missed that there, sorry about that. I’m still shocked at how empty it is.
May 26th, 2009 at 6:16 pm ozsoapbox(Quote)
To give you an idea of just how ridiculous it is take a look at this map. The Criss cross bit that says ‘Melbourne’ is our CBD, it’s the busiest place in Victoria, there are TONS (by Australian standards) of people in it at any given time.
The Docklands is literally next door and is nearly always deserted. There might be a bit of action in the overpriced restaurants on a Saturday night but the contrast is still ridiculous.
View Larger Map
August 17th, 2009 at 1:27 pm Sean(Quote)
I call it “Docklands disease”.
I’m almost certain that its planning was inspired by the 1959 film “On the Beach”.
http://www.melbourneheritage.com/2009/03/26/docklands-disease-spreading-to-melbourne
August 18th, 2010 at
[...] could possibly have happened with Docklands? There’s lots of criticism and ideas (here, here and here). The only plausible explanation I’ve heard is that the development process was [...]