After the disappointing (but not entirely surprising) knock back of a senate enquiry into Scientology by the Rudd government, the storm surrounding the church in Australia appears to have died down.

Xenophon has promised to take the enquiry request to a vote in February but meanwhile questions surrounding the death of Edward McBride remain largely unanswered.

About a week ago now news broke that Edward McBride’s auditor, Lise O’Kane had resigned from the church. O’Kane was one of the members of the church of Scientology who frantically attempted to contact McBride by phone multiple times in the hours leading up to his death.

Of course as news of the resignation broke, seemingly as with most of the information about Scientology that makes its way into the public sphere,  it wasn’t without it’s own small controversy.

Note: Before reading further if you are not familiar with the Edward McBride case I strongly suggest first reading Scientology Soldier’s Sizzling Suicide followed by Unanswered Questions: Scientology and Edward McBride.

News of O’Kane’s resignation first broke on Marty Rathbun’s WordPress hosted blog. Shortly afterwards Rathbun’s blog was allegedly ‘hacked’ and taken down. Following his blog being taken over Rathbun’s email address was also hacked into and taken over.

The original address of Rathbun’s blog is no longer working. I’m assuming as a result of a lack of a backup process the new blog address now has a massive gap between December 13th and the 28th.

News of Lise O’Kane’s resignation was published on December 23rd 2009 and is not available on the new blog address. Luckily Google had a chance to cache the original post before it disappeared.

Due to the temporary accessibility of Google cache I have recreated the post, along with the some of the comments left by O’Kane in response to the 41 comments left by readers.

Brisbane Independent – Lise O’Kane

published December 23rd, 2009.


On December 3, 2009, Lise O’Kane of Brisbane, Australia officially resigned from the Church of Scientology explaining, “I was absolutely disgusted with what David Miscavige has done to our precious technology.

With Reverse Dianetics and Reverse Scientology destroying so many lives worldwide, I realized some time ago the source of that plague was David Miscavige himself.”

A Scientologist for more than 10 years, well respected and well liked throughout Scientology down under, Lise is a highly-skilled auditor and fully-interned Golden Age of Tech Class IV C/S who did her tech internship at AOSH ANZO. For the last five years, she held the posts of Tech Case Supervisor and Auditor in Brisbane org.

Lise O’Kane was also Ed McBride’s auditor. For those of you who don’t know, Ed McBride was a soldier in the Australian army who was soaring after having just completed his auditing program in February 2007. Ed decided to take a day off and inexplicably was found dead 24 hours later. No one knows what happened.

While his death was unrelated to his auditing, the Church’s irresponsible, secretive and evasive responses, coupled with the horrendous revelations of crush regging and human rights abuses worldwide convinced many that the Church had something to hide.

Lise was deeply saddened at the Church’s attitude in regards to the McBride’s tragic loss (and as yet unexplained death of their son and brother) and how it was all about the protection of the Church and no care for the individual.

When the Church received the news that Lise was going to resign, they sent in people to handle her from leaving. Like many staff they were being kept in the dark with no idea what was really going on in the world. So Lise took the opportunity to enlighten them, by handing them a copy of “What happened to training?” from Friends of LRH website.

Finally free from the Church’s suppressive control as dictated by David Miscavige, Lise did what any normal human being would do, she reached out to the Ed McBride’s family expressing her own sorrow and condolences for their loss.

Lise is now an INDEPENDENT SCIENTOLOGIST. Visit Scientology-cult.com to read her official resignation from the Church of Scientology, written December 3, 2009, but just posted today.

She can be reached at liseokane@gmail.com.


Lise // December 23, 2009 at 11:24 pm

Hi Irene, Yes I do have my own thoughts on what happened however as the case is not closed I cannot comment. Thank you for believing me Irene and hopefully I can answer your questions in the future. Have a wonderful Xmas.


Lise // December 23, 2009 at 11:22 pm

just remember the press has twisted things. The case is not closed so I cannot comment at this stage.


Lise // December 23, 2009 at 11:20 pm

hello, Not sure about all aussie Orgs but I know a lot and I mean alot of public have just drifted off the lines quietly not “officially” leaving but just sitting around “waiting for the Org to change”. I think “Hmm, where’s wait on the Know to mystery scale”.

I think a lot of people don’t actually know whats going on and believe that the Church Bridge is the only Bridge and don’t want to give up their “only” option to freedom.

I will be working on that one in my area. Aussie Orgs on a whole I believe are all doing badly with possibly the exception of Melbourne but not sure.


Lise // December 23, 2009 at 10:51 pm

Hi Huck, thank you for your kind words. Yes, lets not make Brisbane staff wrong.

The case is not yet closed so I can’t make any comments but I can assure you that what has been written in the press has been twisted to make us in Brisbane look bad.


Lise // December 23, 2009 at 11:07 pm

Thank you and I will tell all in time. Currently working on some articles to release. And thank you to everyone for all your support, I feel truly blessed to be part of such a good and ethical group.


The resignation letter the article references was tendered to the church on the 3rd December 2009 and published online at Scientology-Cult.com on the 22nd December.

To: COB RTC (Chairman of the Board, Religious Technology Center)
IJC (International Justice Chief)
CJC ANZO (Continental Justice Chief, Australia, New Zealand & Oceania)
CO OSA ANZO (Commanding Officer, Office Special Affairs)
MAA AOSH ANZO (Master At Arms, Advanced Org and Saint Hill
STAFF, BRISBANE ORG

I, Lise O'Kane of Brisbane Australia do hereby announce my resignation from the Church of Scientology. My International Association of Scientologists (IAS) card and Class IV C/S certificate have been handed back to Brisbane Org.

The Church of Scientology management in its current form is a suppressive group who are forwarding illegal orders and downright destructive activities from International Management.

This group under “Command Intention” deal in propaganda and lies and promote this widely throughout the world as “unprecedented expansion”. Orgs are empty and hatred of Scientology is at an all time high yet the focus is to get upstat buildings and raise $ for the IAS to solve the problems and attacks.

This is a wrong. Why?

You cannot get Scientology within the churches anymore. The brilliant tech of LRH is just NOT available and in its place is a squirrel version.

In an article in the Freedom magazine David Miscavige said he answered to the millions of parishioners.

Over the last 10 years that I have been involved in Scientology, I have seen the slow erosion of the Org to what it has become now. The lies and “doublethink” (George Orwell 1984) are rampant through each and every level. The fear to speak your mind is rampant throughout staff members and public.

You can remain in good standing as long as you do exactly what you are told. You are told to LOOK but this really transcends into ONLY WHAT WE TELL YOU TO LOOK AT.

LRH says in Keeping Scientology Working Series #1 that we only get hit for “no” results or “bad” results. Well HELLO??? Where is your responsibility on this. All this trouble is self generated and yet is blamed on “SPs.”

I could write a very long-winded disconnection letter full of refs that are violated daily and broadly but to tell the truth. I really can’t be bothered. So below are some of many major points.

* Personal and widespread comms that refer to the Golden Age of Knowledge (GAK) as the source reference. Squirrel [means "corrupted"]. (attached)

* Embellished symbols by adding GAK microphone symbol with Dn and Scn ones and promoted broadly in magazines. Squirrel. (attached)

* No “real” statistics given in magazines and on Scientology websites with evidence to back them up as true.

* No profiles of any Int management staff on any legitimate website except for David Miscavige.

* The keeping of outer org trainees at FLAG in Clearwater, Florida for way beyond what is needed for them to fire back into their own orgs to produce. Instead keeping them at FLAG to be cash cows for years under the guise of “waiting for perfection”.

* The consistent reg’ing for the IAS as the only solution for the planet and using “rewards” and references out of context to get compliance and suppression on each individual to DO these squirrel programs. (attached)

* The complete and utter nullification of allowing any Scientologist to freely express any grievances or protests that they have.

* The public denial by Tommy Davis that disconnection does not exist. When we ALL know it does.

* The use of priest privileged information collected from PC and ethics folders used to disparage people and also embellishing the contents and then either publishing it through Freedom magazine or through the Scientology system of Ethics Orders labeling people as criminals and other nasty terms.

If this happened to only 2 1/2% then it might be valid but it's a LOT more than that and would be a lot more if half the public and staff members had the courage to speak freely without the fear of having an ethics order or declare order published on them which was intentionally written to disparage and discredit them.

* This week alone, Brisbane Org had Senior C/S Chief CMO, CJC ANZO and a top sea org recruiter directly running the Org on some recruit mission. Nothing personal on these guys they are great people but since when are they our recruiters??? They are management for crying out loud, how off-policy is THAT??

You guys are an absolute shambles. Its not a question of “having to
bypass” because we aren’t doing our jobs. You aren’t doing yours. End of story.

* There is no point trying to correct local orgs because the squirreling comes right from the top and the only way to correct this horrendous scene is by each and every public scientologist to just simply walk away and say NO.

I am now expressing my rights as set by LRH to freedom of speech and I am also taking back my right to freely use my ability gained on Grade 0 “To freely communicate to anyone about anything.” This ability of mine has been squashed for years within the church and yet brilliant in the outside "wog" world.

I am also using my right to assign a condition because I am damned if I am going to wear the condition myself for the lack of assigning it.

I assign the Church of Scientology management and all its entities the condition of TREASON.

I now say NO and hope that others will do the same.

Lise O’Kane
Brisbane, Australia


The two major points in relation to the McBride suicide are that O'Kane asserts that there is an ongoing investigation and that auditing was not to blame for the death of McBride.

I'm not entirely sure what investigation O'Kane is referencing although I suspect it could be a police enquiry. When the Rudd government rejected Xenophon's call for a senate enquiry they stated that "the Tax Office and police were the most appropriate authorities to investigate any complaints."

As for whether auditing had any bearing over McBride's death I'm still out on that one. On one hand O'Kane claims that auditing had nothing to do with McBride's death yet she also tables in her resignation letter a list of, at the very least, questionable undertakings carried out by the church.

As a member of the general public this doesn't exactly inspire confidence that Scientology auditing and the manner in which it is applied wasn't to blame for the death of McBride.

As far as I'm aware the articles O'Kane mentions that she plans to write have not yet been published. I get the feeling that once this current investigation is over, regardless of the findings, that there's a lot of information out there being suppressed that's ready to come out.

One or two renegades are dismissable as possible sour grapes but when you start to see similar stories coming from people based in different parts of the world as they systematically leave the organisation it becomes increasingly hard to pass on the benefit of the doubt.

Hopefully O'Kane's resignation, the unanswered questions surrounding the McBride death and tabled letters from former Australian Scientologists are enough to pass a senate vote in February.

As a society we hold other religious organisations to account when they misbehave so why does it feel like anything related to Scientology inevitably just disappears into a black hole of legal threats and misdirection?


Share this article:
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
  • Facebook
Related posts that might interest you:
  1. Unanswered Questions: Scientology and Edward McBride
  2. Scientology Soldier's Sizzling Suicide
  3. The push to criminalize Scientology in Australia
  4. Russia’s Scientology book ban doesn’t go far enough
  5. Xenophon’s Scientology Senate inquiry fails, what now?