It’s kind of hard to imagine how you’d further degrade the reputation of a film producer who produces documentaries on hilarious conspiracy theories and goes around on the internet proclaiming theories, such as ’9/11 was the work of Israeli nuclear weapons’ are “very convincing”.

Somehow forum posters on Zgeek (a mostly Australian online community) managed to achieve this and Sydney film producer Greg Smith is now planning to sue Zgeek in the supreme court for an astonishing forty two million dollars.

Forty two million plus damages.

It’s generally accepted that if you waltz around the internet proclaiming crazy conspiracy theories as fact you’re going to be torn a new one.

Worse still if you fight back and insist there’s some truth behind whatever crackpot theory of the day it is you believe in now you’re going to send a pheromone out that will attract every flamer, keyboard warrior and troll from within a 6000km radius.

This is just how the internet works.

Greg Smith engaged in such discussion on Zgeek’s forums. So the story goes forumites were discussing the book ‘The Third Truth‘ (which blames 9/11 on Russian submarines and Israeli nuclear weapons) and generally rubbishing it.

Then along comes Greg Smith and declared the arguments presented by the book as ‘very convincing’. Naturally all hell broke loose, an apology was demanded and posts were removed at the bequest of lawyers.

Smith alleges that a group of investors he was involved in pulled out of a movie deal after reading the discussion over The Third Truth on Zgeek. Really… they read some completely unverifiably forum thread and decided to withdraw their millions of dollars?

And where the hell does forty two million PLUS damages come from?

Greg Smith is such an unknown I couldn’t even find a listing on IMDB for his previous work Fortunate Sons, himself or his business partner Jonathan Nolan who is also suing Zgeek. I did however manage to find what I think is a trailer for Smith’s documentary Fortunate Sons.


Update 6th March, 2010: Presumably out of sheer embarassment, the trailer for Fortunate Sons has since been deleted from Youtube.


Oozing of production quality I’m sure you’ll agree the documentary itself must have been millions in the making.

No seriously, forty two freaking million dollars?

Do even A-list producers earn that much per movie?

If you’re going to participate in online discussions and represent something as irresistibly flame attractive such as a conspiracy theory book expect to be taken down hard. There’s just no way around it. The internet isn’t all bunnies and sunshine and neither are its inhabitants.

Smith has until tommorow to submit a corrected application with the supreme court. The first one had a spelling mistake. After that we could witness one of the most interesting court cases in the country.

I seriously doubt anyone in the country is going to opt in to run a public forum if owners are to be held accountable for defamatory remarks posted by it’s users. Some of the larger Australian forums get thousands of posts daily.

The ‘live’ style of conversation many participants enjoy in such forums simply won’t work if every post is to be moderated before it is published.

It’s wholly amusing that a relative unknown has put a forty two million dollar per movie price tag on himself and further has the gall to sue for more to cover reputational damage. If the trailer was anything to go by the quality of work looks to be worth that of about $4.20.

And that’s being generous.

As for forty two million dollars? Well I have a conspiracy theory of my own as to where Greg Smith pulled this number from.

His arse.


Share this article:
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
  • Facebook
Related posts that might interest you:
  1. Z-Geek wins defamation case against Smith And Nolan
  2. Jonathan Nolan threatens legal action over Starwalker
  3. $200 million Holden bailout, have we learnt nothing?
  4. $11.5 million for a security council seat? Get real Rudd.
  5. Michael Trkulja sues search engines over results