Hsinchu firefighters watch man burn on 5th floor
With the mixture of heavy-duty balcony cages, exposed wiring and tiny alleys that dominate the urban landscape of Taiwan, I’ve often wondered what would happen should a serious fire ever break out.
Although it’s doubtful much will change as a result of it, sadly one sixty two year old Hsinchu County man recently found out.
After getting into an argument with his bipolar son over money, Lin Jung-mao (林榮冒) later noticed the building he lived in and owned was on fire.
In a desperate attempt to escape the flames, Lin climbed to the fifth floor and waited to be rescued by the Sinpu Township (新埔) fire department.
Despite 45 firemen arriving on the scene with numerous firetrucks and equipment, firefighters soon discovered that the trucks they had that were equipped with ladders long enough to reach Lin were unable to enter the alleyway the building was in.

The firetrucks that were able to enter the alleyway only had ladders capable of reaching the fourth floor. In the photo below you can see the firefighter’s ladder falling just short of Lin:

At this point an inflatable mattress would have usually been deployed to save Lin, however when they went to pull the mattress out of the truck the firefighters realised they’d ‘forgotten to bring the mattress with them’.
Over the next fifteen minutes the forty five firefighters present, Lin’s wife, family and their neighbours stood and watched the flames creep closer and closer to Lin.

Amidst Lin’s screams for help, fuelled by the confusion of why nobody was helping him, the fire eventually engulfed Lin and he burned to death. Upon realising their blunder, the firefighters had no choice but to silently watch on in horror as Lin’s death took place.
During his final moments, Lin’s wife and neighbours ran amongst them pleading for someone to save Lin and wondering with despair why nobody was doing anything.
I have no idea what passes through one’s mind when you realise nobody is going to help you and a raging inferno us drawing nearer and nearer… but I suspect it’s one of complete and utter heart-breaking terror.
Following the controlling of the blaze, it was revealed that Lin’s argument with his thirty two year old son had been over a disputed regular payment to the son’s bank account of $5000 TWD ($172 USD).
Lin’s wife had apparently had enough and declined to make the monthly deposits her son had demanded from them which they’d initially agreed to. Following a heated argument with their son, Lin’s wife took the family dog out for a walk.
Meanwhile the son doused the lower levels of the building with petrol and ignited the fire that would claim the life of his father.

Lin’s son fled the scene but suffered second-degree burns to his face and hands. He slept overnight in a factory he worked at but due to his injuries had to present himself to a hospital the next day.
Upon presenting himself the hospital staff notified the police and Lin’s son was arrested.
In the political aftermath of the fire, Fire Bureau Director Wu Wu-tai (吳武泰) had been transferred to a non-executive position. The District Prosecutors Office have also launched an investigation into the forty five firefighters present, to ascertain whether or not there is a case of “criminal responsibility” to answer for.
Hsinchu County Commissioner Chiu Ching-chun yesterday paid a visit to Lin’s family, offering the government’s condolences over the incident (accompanied by what appears to be one inappropriately jolly fellow):

Chiu also stated that the Hsinchu government would not “avoid its responsibilities” (cha-ching!).
With these fire deathtrap alleys a staple feature of every Taiwanese city and county (yes, even Taipei City is full of them), I’m quite frankly surprised horror deaths like Lin’s aren’t a much more frequent occurrance.
Good to know that you might very well end up being on your own should you ever find your building on fire and unfortunately live above the fourth floor…
Sources: Apple Daily (January 16th, 2013), Taipei Times and Apple Daily (January 17th, 2013).



January 17th, 2013 at 2:25 pm mike(Quote)
I saw that in the Apple Daily yesterday too. What an appalling way to die.
January 17th, 2013 at 2:31 pm Olaf(Quote)
If they follow standard Taiwan procedure, from now on they will bring at least one inflatable mattress to EVERY fire, even if it is a one-storey storage or just a bunch of old tires burning.
In 2000 or 2001, shortly after DPP won presidency, three people died in a river in Jiayi county. They were working there in the river bed and after their supervisor had left them he received a message that due to rainfall in the mountains the water level may soon rise.
He could not warn them in time, so they stood in the middle of the river, clinging to each other for support. And from there things only went down.
Firefighters arrived and tried to fire a line to them, but missed. They only had one cartridge, so someone raced back to Jiayi to get new ones. The only shop selling them wanted to see cash first – 30k. (for one?)
They called the police, to get a helicopter from them, but police said this was on water, call the coast guard. They called the coast guard, but they said this is inland, call the police.
TV was there, so for 1.5 hours this became a very well-documented drowning. Anyway, one of the results was that as long as water was involved, even if it was less than 1m deep, a helicopter was hovering over the scene – something so ridiculous even the local media noticed…
January 17th, 2013 at 3:00 pm mike(Quote)
Swimming lessons, FFS.
January 17th, 2013 at 6:54 pm Chububobcat(Quote)
I wonder why few of the houses (very very few from my encounters) have fire suppresion systems in them.
Most places in Taichung are 4 and 5 story buildings in allies that are impposible to navigate a large fire engine into. So wouldn’t that be a common sense addition to any building?
As for swimming~ I am not going to say that what happened to those 3 people could have been adverted entirely had they been taught to swim. However, I find it really mind boggling how few people in Taiwan actually know how to swim even enough to be able to save their lives or attempt to save their lives in the event of a flood.
Espcially considering that we live on an island, frequently hit by typhoons, and drowned in torential rains that flood the streets and parking garges of apartment complexes.
January 17th, 2013 at 7:20 pm mike(Quote)
“I am not going to say that what happened to those 3 people could have been adverted entirely had they been taught to swim.”
Actually, what they probably needed to know in that case was not so much how to do backstroke but how to read the movement of water in the river and to judge the strength of the current.
You’d think that would have been obvious to all concerned before they started working in the river bed, but then this is Taiwan.
January 17th, 2013 at 10:12 pm Chububobcat(Quote)
True that probably would have helped a lot too. I know that is what we were told in my Jr High, that if you get trapped in a flash flood or some how end up in a river like that you should if possible attempt to swim with the river and at an angle to reach the shore line.
Does that actually work I don’t know, thankfully I have never had to test that theory. However, using the same logic I have seen firemen fish people and animals out of rivers by going in above them with a line attached swimming slightly up stream and horizontally in order to reach the victim. So reading this section…
with out too much knowledge of these powershot line things, I am confused why they didn’t just use this rope
tie it to a fireman and throw him into the river up stream and rescue the people that way.
Or does it revolve back around to need manditorially volentary swimming lessons in all schools now, or at least in manditory in fire station recruits.
January 18th, 2013 at 2:09 am mike(Quote)
Chubobobcat: I’d say there’s nothing more needed than a couple of brain cells to rub together.
January 18th, 2013 at 8:13 am lemmiwinks(Quote)
Clearly the articles you select and re-post here do not give a balanced picture of Taiwan, but damn it’s hard to not get the impression of quite a dysfunctional society. Certainly interpersonal and family relationships seem messed up.
As for the unfortunate fellow in the fire, well it’s easy to be an armchair expert, but personally, given a choice between burning alive Joan of Arc style or my best effort at jumping onto the ladder (albeit a bit short one end) I know which I’d choose.
January 18th, 2013 at 1:23 pm Oz(Quote)
Ironically this is the main reason I started paying an interest in Taiwanese local language media, as it’s rare for any of these stories to get translated. And even when they are, they usually leave large chunks of information out.
Reading the English news in Taiwan is a bit of a wank. It’s all high-brow politics and mostly stuff I couldn’t give a crap about. I like these weird local level stories as they really open up the culture of the country I live in.
Day to day life in Taiwan is greatly at odds with the rather bland portrayal it gets in the English speaking media. I’m just trying to catalogue some of it.
January 18th, 2013 at 7:57 pm TaiwanTeacher(Quote)
Adding my two cents:
My former brother-in-law, Pablo, had the misfortune of discovering a fire in his neighbor’s house while a mother and child were still inside. The two tenants fled the house and onto the porch, only to discover that they had “security ironwork” installed that encaged them, and the key to unlock the gate was still inside the flaming house.
The saws-all I gave him a month before for Christmas was useless, as there was no extension chord long enough reach to the ironwork. Pablo tried desperately to hammer off the padlock until he was driven away by the heat.
He stood back, left to sadly watch, as a mother laid over her child, trapped in their own protective zoocage, and slowly burned to death…
January 18th, 2013 at 8:01 pm TaiwanTeacher(Quote)
Footnote: He WAS the welder who had built the ironcage years before. Tragically, he had no acetylene for his cutting torch that day.
January 19th, 2013 at 12:39 am mike(Quote)
“It’s all high-brow politics…”
Generally, it would have to get a lot “higher” before you could say it was even that.
January 19th, 2013 at 3:56 am mike(Quote)
“He stood back, left to sadly watch, as a mother laid over her child, trapped in their own protective zoocage, and slowly burned to death…”
That is a horrible story.
January 20th, 2013 at 1:07 pm Oz(Quote)
@TT
Upon seeing the rows and rows of gated balconies getting trapped in a fire was the first thing that crossed my mind.
All very well to have padlocked escape hatches but who carries the key around with them?
Thankfully I’ve only lived in one place with the bars but if I ever find myself in one again I’m just going to leave the key in the lock outside. Honestly who is going to rock up with a ladder and break into a 3rd story or higher apartment at street level?
I know it can be done but with all the CCTV around and what not…
That and even if it did happen I’d rather have my shit stolen than wind up as KFC.
January 20th, 2013 at 1:55 pm TaiwanTeacher(Quote)
Perhaps the ironwork should be installed using an “explosive bolt” and piezo-electric trigger? I’m think that something which could be easily triggered in an emergency, yet make such a ruckus that thieves would be unlikely to try popping them for fear of attracting attention, just might do.
Then again, I think too much, or so they tell me…
January 20th, 2013 at 6:37 pm Oz(Quote)
If you could make the system waterproof, heat resistant (fire) and not activatable from the outside (kinda defeats the purpose of the “security”) then sure why not.
Don’t think most Taiwanese would bother though. “Pssh, like that’s going to happen to me!”